March 29, 2005

Civil liability for computer viruses

“Computer Viruses and Civil Liability: A Conceptual Framework.” That's the title of a recent 57-page article in the Fall 2004 issue of the American Bar Association's Tort Trial and Insurance Practice Law Journal, pp. 123-179. (The article is also online at http://www.law.unsw.edu.au/staff/devilliersm/docs/VIRUS-II.pdf.)

The article starts with the following abstract:

“This article analyzes a negligence cause of action for inadvertent transmission of a computer virus. It provides an introduction to the principles of operation and detection of viruses and analyzes the elements of negligence liability in the context of virus infection. A final section discusses and analyzes litigation complications that are a direct result of the dynamic and unique nature of virus and virus detection technology.”

Three of the major topics are: Operation and Structure of Computer Viruses, Virus Infection as Negligence Cause of Action, and Litigation Complications.

In his discussion of the negligence cause of action, Meiring de Villliers applies the traditional tort analysis of duty, breach, cause in fact, and proximate cause . Moreover, virtually all (if not all) of his case citations are to traditional non-computer common law cases. However, he includes a detailed technical analysis of viruses and their propagation and prevention and applies the common law cases and principles to the current computer problems.

He concludes with the following, part of which is similar to the abstract:

“This article analyzes the elements of a negligence cause of action for inadvertent transmission of a computer virus. The analysis emphasizes the importance of an understanding of virus and virus detection technology, as well as the economics of virus prevention, in negligence analysis. The classic principles of negligence apply to a virus case, but a plaintiff 's case may be significantly complicated by the unique and dynamic nature of the technologies involved.”
Posted by ajlevy at March 29, 2005 9:48 AM
Site Meter